Home Wine News Articles Shop for Wine Accessories About Links Downloads Contact

Good Grape Wine Company

Left side of the header
Right side of the header

Perfection in a Bottle?

In the rolling hills of Tuscany the Frescobaldi family has been making wine for 30 generations and some 700 years.  Yet, it was only in 1995, when the family aligned with the Mondavi’s, America’s first wine family, that a cross-continental collaboration was borne in Montalcino, an area within the Tuscan region famous for its Brunello, a 100% Sangiovese wine.

Luce della Vite, meaning “Light of the Vine,” is the resulting winery even as gyrations in the Mondavi family business have blunted the initial collaboration of the two families in jointly creating a world class winery.  Now run exclusively by the Frescobaldi’s with investment from Michael Mondavi (and imported to the U.S. by Michael Mondavi’s Folio Wine Partners), their flagship wine, sourced from 29 DOCG certified acres, the 2006 Brunello di Montalcino, has been awarded a perfect 100-point score by James Suckling, former European Bureau Chief for Wine Spectator, now leading his own wine project at his eponymous web site.

This introduction would be apropos of nothing besides ornate wine writer affectations were it not necessary to create the milieu for what is an interesting convergence of issues in the wine world.

Encapsulated in this one wine, from an Italian wine family, formerly aligned with the scion of American wine and imported to the U.S. by his son and given a perfect 100-point score by a former critic with the Wine Spectator, many of the contemporary issues of the wine world can be examined and pondered…


•  A 100-point score

Is there such a thing as a perfect wine?  I’ll leave the question open-ended while noting that my own scoring only goes to 99.  In the realm of subjectivity, can something like wine or art achieve perfection?

•  The fallibility of wine criticism

Stephen Tanzer, another notable wine critic, gave the same wine 92 points.  Wine Enthusiast scored it 93 points.  Robert Parker’s Italian wine critic (and recently anointed California reviewer), Antonio Galloni, gave it a 90.  While a 90, 92 or 93 is a good score, the difference between a 93 and a 100 certainly points to a margin spread that provides more questions than answers about the wine.

•  Crossing the digital divide

Suckling, ex-Wine Spectator, is out of the paper magazine business and running his own web site with subscriptions, a business that is less than a year old.  He has lived in Tuscany for a number of years and knows Brunello wines well.  However, anointing 100-point wines isn’t something critics do lightly or without thought.  So, when he declares that, “The 2006 vintage for Brunello di Montalcino is the new benchmark…” is he genuinely reviewing the vintage and the region’s most notable vintner or is this his attempt at market-making relevance akin to Robert Parker Jr.’s declaration of ’82 Bordeaux as “superb” when others weren’t as bullish?

•  Critical scores affect on inelastic pricing

While so-called “cult” wines get a bad rap based on their stylistic profile, the reality is that prices are high because of scarcity – more people want to buy it then there is wine available to buy.  Suckling’s 100-point score for the Luce Brunello is oft-repeated on numerous retailer web sites where the retail price has been raised from a suggested retail price of $89.99 to an average price of $127 based on data.  Meanwhile, the 2005 Luce Brunello is being discounted and has an average price of $84 based on data.  It should be noted, that save for Suckling on the ’06, both wines were reviewed consistently with scores in the low 90s.

•  A global style

It’s interesting to note that Suckling’s tasting note for the Brunello called it, “…A wine with soul.”  Meanwhile Antonio Galloni noted, “The sheer concentration and depth of fruit are remarkable, but ultimately this comes across as a heavy, labored Brunello with limited finesse.”

So, which is it?  Is it a soulful wine or one with limited finesse?  The U.S. has the largest global appetite for Brunello with some reporting that upwards of 25% of all Brunelli produced is imported to the states.  Given that, is the Luce Brunello made to appeal to more of a fruit-forward palate that is often found in the U.S., a style of wine that Wine Spectator and Suckling have lauded in the wake of Robert Parker, the so-called, global style?


I’ll save the full review of the wine for my column…in the meantime, I’m reminded that the conversations about the people, personalities, ideas and issues in the wine world are often as interesting as what’s in the glass and that’s certainly the case with the 2006 Luce della Vite Brunello di Montalcino, a 100-points for interest and conversational fodder and less for the actual wine.  For me, that’s just perfect.


Posted in, Good Grape Daily: Pomace & Lees. Permalink | Comments (34) |


On 08/25, .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

Perhaps the fact that four reviewers gave the wine four different scores (one very distinctly so) illuminates the fact that critical judgement of a wine is very subjective. If subjectivity is therefore a part of reviewing wines, then readers should be subjective in their reading of wine reviews.

On 08/25, 1WineDude wrote:

One man’s 100-pointer is another man’s 89-er, apparently. wink

On 08/25, Colorado Wine Press wrote:

Perfection in wine is nonsense. Reading an ESPN blog a few weeks ago about the new QBR and QB “perfection” made me think about wine perfection. Don’t mean to shill, but saying a wine is perfect is ridiculous; it could always be better… Check out my reworking of that post to describe wine:

On 09/04, Werbeartikel wrote:

Trying to calculate shipping costs for a bottle of champagne that I want to send overseas and don’t have the bottle with me. Anyone who could weigh a bottle and let me know would help.

On 09/14, artist portfolios wrote:

Yellow Submarine was released on the album ‘Revolver’ in 1966. Revolver was somewhat of a turning point for the band, as it was a mix of the rock and roll and folk-oriented rock. They had previously performed, along with the harder edged, and somewhat strange psychedelic sound that would come to define their next few years’ output.

On 10/12, real resume help wrote:

I’ve applied for a few jobs as my first job. I’ve never had a job before or interview besides babysitting and I dressed normally for those.

On 11/22, st john family lawyer wrote:

The family law firm will treat your individual case as if it was their own. They believe that marriage and family matters are highly sensitive and should be handled with the utmost care.

On 11/28, Free Cell Phone Spy Software wrote:

Great post, what you said is really helpful to me. I can not Agree With You Anymore. I Have Been talking with my friend about, he though it is really interesting as well.

On 12/20, .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

There is obviously a lot to know about this.I think you made some good points in Features also.
how to get rid of ants naturally

On 12/21, .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

You are so talented in writing. God is really using you in tremendous methods. You are doing a great job! This was a wonderful article.Thank you
gold price per ounce

On 12/25, .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

Thank you very much for taking your time to create this very informative site.I have learned a lot from your site.
price of gold per gram

On 12/28, retail industry wrote:

India retailing is a path-breaking interface portal. Addressed and directed towards the retailing community across the world, the portal provides a wide-angle view and analysis
of the business of retail in India. retail trends

On 12/28, latest fashion news wrote:

Images fashion strives to provide a balance of timely, credible business news and key fashion trends. fashion trend forecast 2012

On 02/04, .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

Wonderful job right here. I seriously enjoyed what you had to say. Keep going because you absolutely bring a new voice to this topic. Not many people would say what youve said and still make it interesting.
cell spyware

On 02/26, ipad 2 case wrote:

Wow,,, it is good to hear that they are into this business so many many years.. for sure the taste of their product is genuine.

On 03/13, luxury jewelery wrote:

Thank you for the introduction! I learn a lot from your post!

On 03/20, burger king coupons wrote:

It is useful blog for everyone and i have got many new ideas and information with this blog.Thanks for sharing wonderful information.

On 03/23, UK Dissertations wrote:

I was studying some of your content on this internet site and I believe this site is rattling informative ! Continue posting .

On 03/26, TN Pas Cher wrote:


On 03/30, maquina de coser wrote:

There is obviously a lot to know about this.I think you made some good points in Features also like it with!

On 04/15, Jaguard x type car parts wrote:

I think i have seen this kind of topic in other website. Well funny that the design is almost the same

On 04/15, jaguar x type online car parts wrote:

Obtaining Toyota, Nissan, Ford, ford and Jaguar parts is definitely fast, no cost and has a large network of high quality discount suppliers. On their website, it is especially easy to request exactly what Bentley car piece is needed and turn into connected with numerous suppliers and a lot of different fees ensuring the lowest price.

On 04/25, how to get rid of bed bugs naturally wrote:

Don’t have any words to appreciate this post…..I am really impressed ....the person who created this post surely knew the subject well…Thanks for sharing this with us.

On 04/25, how to get rid of fruit flies in the house wrote:

This is a really great post I found some really good information here.This is a very helpful post.

On 05/23, pottery barn coupon code free shipping wrote:

Is exceedingly good type publishing. I like it and I appreciate you for your effort.Thanks a lot for sharing this news with us.

On 06/05, dominos pizza coupon code wrote:

I am satisfied with the content that you mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great article

On 06/19, reverse address lookup business wrote:

There is obviously a lot to know about this.I think you made some good points in Features also.Thanks keep it up guys…

On 06/24, negotiating with creditors wrote:

Now this one here is my favorite and I do love it really. I hope I can get these things here done just like that.

On 06/24, we buy houses bay area wrote:

wow. I just thought that everything in this is going to be so fine and i love this perfection in a bottle. i love it then.

On 06/25, traitement varicosités wrote:

Perfection in a bottle? Well if a family is running a business just like that then that’s their families’ tradition or something.

On 06/29, montreal web designer wrote:

There are actually people that are just like that who are looking for a perfect one for their bottle. that’s life.

On 07/04, home inspection montreal wrote:

The way the article was made was great . Even the title itself can make the readers take a glimpse and read it afterward . Such a nice site as well .

On 07/11, Modesto carpet cleaners wrote:

There’s always a lot of new adventures Everyday. Totally impressive..

On 08/02, kitchen aid hand mixer wrote:

Definitely an interesting page you’ve got in here. Impressive indeed.


View More Archives