good grape daily: pomace & lees free run: field notes from a wine life around the wine blogosphere wine: a business doing pleasure good grape wine reviews new world red wine influences wine white wine wine blog news robert parker wine bloggers notes & dusty bottle items wine sediments wine business wine blogs historical wine book excerpts tasting safari: wines you can buy online cluetrain manifesto revisited winecast: a year in collaboration wine spectator robert mondavi wine blogger wine marketing indy food & wine vin de napkin vinography wine blogging dr. vino appellation watch: midwest regional review new vine logistics alice feiring american wine blog awards wine critics wine reviews cameron hughes wine books luxury wine tom wark natural wine gary vaynerchuk oregon pinot noir wall street journal wine best wine blogs wine writers best wine bloggers biodynamic wine a really goode job california wine robert mondavi day robert mondavi winery fermentation blog penner-ash wine research wine ratings fred franzia tyler colman steve heimoff amazon.com southern wine & spirits 100-pt scale grape stories wine & spirits magazine mike steinberger church wine wine tasting notes vintank silver oak trader joe's wine wine and spirits daily indiana wine matt kramer champagne slender wine direct-to-trade murphy-goode winery wine technology notre dame football stormhoek inertia beverage group wine enthusiast bordeaux sparkling wine wine and the economy wine distribution terry theise wine.com biodynamics allocated wine wine news reading between the wines rodney strong the wine makers tv inniskillin hr 5034 oregon bounty oregon cuisinternship wine advertising wine review jim laube wine ethics gourmet magazine three dolla koala sonoma pinot noir appellation america rockaway wine market council open that bottle night zinfandel wine online winery marketing wine trends lynn penner-ash sommelier journal wine advocate rockaway vineyards good grape augmented reality hugh macleod pinot noir crushpad wine cellartracker dan berger indiana gourmet food allocated cabernet the wine line core wine drinkers janet trefethen bruce reizenman luxury wine marketing wall street journal wine columnists "frankenwine" wine authors nbwa old vine zinfandel cluetrain manifesto down under by crane lake unified symposium jackson-triggs vidal ice wine clif winery name your own price mirror wine company texas bbq wine pairing prince's hot chicken king estate guinness advertising 2007 stoneleigh pinot noir wine pr wineamerica wine wisdom lewin's equation 1winedude chacha rudolf steiner wine expedition fat tire beer mothervine supplements continuum whyte horse winery iphone wine apps. palate press wine blogging strategies wine certification the traveling vineyard wine and art jason kroman alloutwine.com wine mou hess collection wine social media expensive wine trends wines and vines kelly fleming cabernet the new yorker ted lemon ted jansen hourglass wine murphy-goode wine trading down dip johnnie walker chateau latour planet bordeaux sherry wine paul clary blog gracianna wine wine cartoons alan goldfarb fusebox wine moms who need wine geocaching brigitte armenier rockaway wine red bicyclette social media topps augmented reality rancho zabaco zinfandel woot wine the new frugality patio wine bryan q. miller argentina wine zephyr adventures barolo santana dvx au revoir to all that formula business ordinance .wine the best pinot noir food & wine magazine a year in wine apple iphone man's search for meaning st. helena catholic church new zealand wine sanford chardonnay lettie teague nba liquor advertising noble pig award of excellence ericca robinson andy warhol quotes fermentation anthony dias blue home winemaking consumer shopping research darwinism wine star awards tastingroom.com bruliam wine generation y. wine april fool's day wine snooth karen macneil music and wine german riesling secret sherry society cult wines wine video game russian river valley pinot wine appellations reset "old world wine amazon.com wine california cabernet paso robles wine sales hailey trefethen park avenue catering fine wine marketing wine tasting journal wine competitions national beer wholesalers association clos lachance dr. oz yellow tail wine jon fredrikson wine blogging wednesday climber red priceline.com drew bledsoe john james dufour america eats willamette valley wines of chile specialty wine retailers association judd's hill rose wine recession wine wine & spirits daily firestone vineyards wine trivia robert parker's bitch eryn supple the grateful palate heidi barrett parks and recreation wine umami swanson alexis cabernet disney wine program value wines brand butlers american wine blogs forty-five north winery wine press release hong kong u.s. wine 2006 hess collection monterey chardonnay adler fels wines & vines kelly fleming interview the pour oregon food and wine dan cederquist bodeans mitch schwartz hourglass cabernet italian wine merchant dependable wine sutter home videos inexpensive wine jay miller keep walking wines that rock steve perry aussie wine glut clary ranch pinot noir john tyler wine wine economy mary ewing-mulligan non-profits and wine ebob paul blart: mall cop phillip armenier red bicyclette pinot noir wine blogosphere ge smart grid augmented reality trefethen family vineyards california zinfandel wineshopper aspirational marketing clark smith wine book publishing russian river valley ani difranco peru wine trip barbaresco michael steinberger value wine jamie oliver jess jackson massale selection wine & spirits magazines kenny shopsin next generation apple the psychology of wine the vintners art australian wine vinexpo jay mcinerney the gaslight anthem the pioneer woman james laube sylvester pinot noir goodguide korbel wine blobbers oregon travel tokalon winery not-for-profit poseurs macari vineyards sette 7 swanson vineyards sunbox eleven wine winery sponsorship champagne sales wine criticism cork'd 2008 vina mar reserva sauvignon blanc randy caparoso wine + music midwest wine culture chimney rock elevage cornell enology wine tycoon game stavin kelly fleming national wine & spirits kurt andersen " "new world wine" charlie weis sugar free wine a very goode job 2007 sean minor four bears pinot noir trefethen generation y and wine 2009 auction napa valley sonoma county wine wipes san francisco wine competition clary ranch tim hanni hunningbird wine beaux freres jon bonne the wine case climber white agency nil judgment of paris women in wine oregon pinot gris three-tier carmenere wine heist purpose-idea rose wine sales vincellar dominic foppoli discoveries pathfinder wine bar bets the winemakers tv australia wine fantesca amy poehler wine micro sites umami chris phelps vegas wine qpr wines jimmy clausen winery hospitality 2007 forty-five north cabernet franc alpine for dummies 2008 honig sauvignon blanc 1% for the planet wine industry news negociant wine business monthly 2008 food & wine winemaker of the year eric asimov travel oregon jordan winery little zagreb wine magazines howard schultz paul mabray wine blogging ethics youtube cheap wine wine bard weds wine dj journey three dollar koala pinot noir reviews chronicle wine ed mccarthy wine to relax erobertparker bottle shock movie sketches of spain red bicyclette court paul gregutt trefethen oak knoll cabernet sauvignon zinfandel reviews tasting note desciptors natural winemaking wine content klinker brick maria thun bad wine mumm napa slate wine columnist wine pricing wine blog awards 2010 preakness stakes pork tenderloins wine & spirits restaurant poll 2010 eat me kenny shopsin amazon kindle wine politics what is terroir wine purchasing wine nose good wine under 20 the hold steady paste magazine sensory evaluation petite sirah wine points the press-democrat oregon cuisinternship winner blog contests vignoles wine columns mirror wine joe roberts e-myth revisited bennett lane winery champagne and business a history of wine words marco capelli music + wine indianapolis patz & hall sonoma coast pinot noir notes on a cellar book wine tycoon video game oak alternatives cabernet bottle shock economy chronicle wines radiohead doubleback wine chateau thomas wine parker defamation blackstone wine trefethen fallow obama napa valley auction sonoma county wine french wine marketing vino chapeau wine medal winners petaluma pinot wine industry zap wine jr. san francisco chronicle wine ice wine c.g. di arie resveratrol woman in wine organic wineries oregon wine snobs wine is the new black expensive wine will hoge wine spies gapingvoid rose summer wine corkd foppoli wines tamari torrontes dirty south wine firestone contest doug frost whuffie factor wine reality show wine label design duane hoff obama wine digital signage wine retail the fifth taste dominus bellagio wine the wine blue book conundrum winery customer service julie and julia texas for dummies wine collection shorttrack ceo vintage of the decade markham mark of distinction sonoma wine company spike your juice celia masyczek jim koch pinot main street winery party of five theme song wine spectator restaurant awards zig ziglar drvino.com wine direct shipping wine humor altar wine good wine livingston cellars persimmon creek vineyards liberty school cabernet sauvignon german wine oh westside road scott becker randall grahm indiana miss america lewis perdue pbs john trefethen elliot essman wine intelligence research steroids in baseball publishing trends wine laws biodynamic wine health research 2007 waters crest "night watch" late harvest wine clif bar wine cheap wines rick mirer rachel alexandra 500 things to eat before it's too late wine & spirits guinness beer 2006 brancott pinot noir wine public relations facebook + wine millenials and wine penner ash deb harkness cowboy mouth wine evaluation dark & delicious biod alpana singh dos equis commercials wine and sense of smell tim mondavi traminette wine mobile applications rick mirer wine wine blogging tips professional culinary institute adobe road the the lost symbol wine stories wine 2.0 schotts micellany hugh johnson alloutwine cooper's hawk winery triple bottom line jim gordon kelly fleming wine mike hengehold di arie rose napa cab. napa cabernet amazon wine constellation wine washington wine john hughes '47 cheval blanc bordeaux reconquest santasti kevin zraly paul clary sweet wines zinfandel producers california wine for dummies best wine blog us wine sales dessert wine french paradox dark side of the rainbow gallo thomas pellechia wine spectator top 100 2009 cinderella wine deck wine lindsay ronga batgirl wine top chef hardy wallace firestone wine contest burger wine lonely island where the hell is matt southern gothic wine food revolution wine tasting rooms viktor frankl chateau petrus barack obama + wine sanford pinot noir rombauer digital marketing obama inauguration michael ruhlman wine spectator wine reviews karadeci the business of wine iphone wine mobile apps winery promotions whole foods wine first blush juice cult cabernet boston beer company trinchero southern wine and spirits wine lists adam strum tinybottles 100 point system vineyard church communion wine mark squires wine and music scheurebe sherry wine tycoon healdsburg terroir wine branding global wine partners wine terroir
April 10 2010
I sense that the progress made on winery direct shipping and the three-tier system has reached its crossroads—a preaching of the choir to respective constituents without broader implications (or action) for the dynamics at hand.
Five years after Granholm and much progress has been made. Yet, the Wine and Spirits Wholesalers Association (WSWA) convention this week indicated that the three-tier is digging in, not conceding to progress, and certainly not submitting to the slightest notion that the three-tier system isn’t just an ideological struggle—it’s a survival struggle for thousands and thousands of domestic wineries.
Put another way, in political terms, there isn’t any, “Reaching across the aisle.”
That reality is that there isn’t a single person in the wine business that is a proponent of dismantling the three-tier system. None. No, instead, it’s just the simple notion of access to market—where access is currently unavailable or unwieldy.
Yet, while winery shipping advocates are doing noble work, the time is nigh for a functional evolution from spreading the message to implementing action.
Over the course of the last two days, two pieces of news, while not connected, highlight this all-important point.
First, Wines & Vines magazine reports that the number of wineries in the U.S. has topped 7,000 with almost 30% growth in number since 2005. California represents an increase of 670 wineries in that same period.
Yet, 76% of these wineries are categorized as producing under 5,000 cases of wine a year – the area that is most impacted by an inability to secure distribution.
In a stunning statistic that bears frequent repeating, according to Wines & Vines: 6% of wineries produce 93% of all wine by volume. If you look at that from 180 degrees, 94% of wineries produce 7% of wine by volume.
While the WSWA wants to push rhetoric about the three-tier not being a broken system, the cold, hard facts indicate that this is as classic of a case of Main Street versus Wall Street as you’re likely ever going to see. The sheer numbers indicate that this is akin to the conversation about Wal-Mart and the destruction of the family business. Period.
Now, I understand the argument that many wineries start their business without a clear understanding of who and how they are going to sell their product within the constraints of the current system, and that there are more domestic wineries than there is market to support them, yet I still can’t get beyond the fact that not only is the three-tier system an artifact of a different era that requires evolution in philosophy if not application, but it’s also a system that is governed by dollars and cents instead of sense.
In a separate news release, winery trade association WineAmerica announced an advancement of an alliance with shipping compliance company ShipCompliant, offering turnkey registration and management of compliance needs for direct shipping in 32 states, called “Easywinelicensing.”
Much of the debate on the three-tier system versus wineries consists of a requested support for advocacy by various groups. While noble and helpful, the revolution has to start within the winery community itself, one winery at a time.
By analogy (and pardon the indelicate nature of said analogy), if you have cancer you’re sure as hell not writing checks to the American Cancer Society to support research and advocacy, you’re getting treatment for yourself to get better.
94% of the wineries that produce 7% of wine by volume need to treat themselves like a sick patient, which is certainly more important than supporting advocacy that appears to be at loggerheads.
While not inexpensive, I can’t imagine a better investment than a small winery stepping up to the plate to secure ease of paperwork administration and compliance by using ShipCompliant for direct-to-consumer sales and then heading over to Inertia Beverage Group for access to market for direct-to-trade sales.
The reality is that without individual progress that marks itself as a broad movement for direct-to-consumer and direct-to-trade sales, and use of the tools for wineries to heal themselves, all of the advocacy in the world isn’t going to matter.
Only when the WSWA and the three-tier system see a fomenting movement that makes up a collective whole that requires them to sit-up, take notice and amend a system that is currently predicated on preservation instead of progress will we see real change.
And, while, we’ve all been drinking in a lot of hot air from all points, I prefer something that sits in my glass.
April 8 2010
I recently heard a heartwarming tale of a father who made up a thrilling story of bravery and heroism for his son every night for years, each night adding a little bit to the same premise, extending the narrative for days upon weeks upon years until eventually the boy outgrew the charm and ‘The Story’ faded from daily tradition into family lore, waiting to become legend.
Unfortunately, this post has nothing to do with a fanciful story of optimism built chapter by chapter, sounding like a Mitch Albom plot outline—unless stream of consciousness can carry an ISBN number.
No, instead, I want to juxtapose the warm fuzzies against the story of wine criticism, which operates in a bizarro alternate universe to our do-gooding Dad story.
Every day, someone, somewhere, is committing thought, energy and tap-taps on the keyboard in examining the state of wine criticism, both historically and in its current form, sometimes extending the narrative, sometimes not. Amateurs versus professionals, blind versus non-blind, points versus non-points, all of it is open season. What is certain in this verbal jousting on the simple act of examining a wine is that little is left to the imagination; it’s a coarse nude shot when a little cheesecake would do just fine.
Frankly, the examination of wine criticism induces somnambulistic slumber akin to reading the healthcare bill.
My recommendation as an alternative to the onanistic pursuit of wine evaluation and those that proffer opinion on viability of said criticism? Drink and analyze wine only in the company of friends and food and read criticism only from those who analyze wine in the company of friends and food.
You want good stories as a result? You’ll get good stories. And, some laughs, too, absent a natural conversation starter.
I recently joined David Honig, Publisher of Palate Press, and Louis Calli, a retail wine buyer, for a Napa tasting.
The line-up was a nice representative sample of Napa Cabernets across price points, and they were, indeed, all samples sent by the wineries.
What truly was interesting about the tasting is the running commentary that is at least as equally interesting as the wine analysis—particularly when many of the wines don’t have an evident story, more on that in a second, though.
We tasted through:
2006 Louis Martini Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon ABV: 14.2 / SRP: $27
2006 V. Sattui Preston Vineyards Napa Valley Cabernet ABV: 14.6% / SRP: $45
2005 Swanson Vineyards “Alexis” Cabernet Sauvignon ABV: 14.8% / SRP: $75
2006 Wallis Family Estate “Diamond Mountain” Cabernet Sauvignon ABV: 14.6% / SRP: $85
2005 Hunter III Cabernet Sauvignon ABV: 14.5% / SRP: $50
2006 Bennett Lane Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon ABV: 14.5% / SRP: $55
2006 Cornerstone Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon ABV: 14.5% / SRP: $59
For me, all of the wines were nice, each representing something positive, as if that’s not faint praise. The V. Sattui was very approachable; the Hunter III was interesting and compelling with something funky going on with the nose that reminded me of bilge water, in a good way. The Bennett Lane was a superstar. Cornerstone is an exemplary wine, and the one that Louis deemed “worth $100,” which is ironic given that it doesn’t cost $100 anymore. The Louis Martini was dark and complex, a hint of candied sweetness and a touch of heat marring an otherwise dandy wine.
The wines were generally fantastic.
But, more fantastic was the conversation, which stands in for legitimate criticism and evidentiary marketing from the winery that indicates any type of story or hook.
Absent a story, I learned:
• Sometime in the last 10 to 15 years MSG variants were legalized for spraying in vineyards. Come to find out that there is/was a semi-controversial product on the market called AuxiGrow that is about 1/3 L-glutamic acid, the “G” in MSG (thanks also to Thomas Pellechia for helping me with some independent insight on this). Perhaps, a reason that California wines have taken a turn for the savory over the same period.
• Maple and brown sugar Life cereal is a good product for Cali Cabernet palate training.
• Fruit Loops are a good product for Central Coast Viognier palate training
• Wine Notes is a good iPhone wine app.
Here’s the thing about the wine tasting amongst friends and food. All of the running commentary and analysis of the wine would be made more interesting if there was a back-story to the wine, which was otherwise absent in all of the marketing materials that accompanied the wines.
In the business bestseller “Made to Stick” by Chip Heath and Dan Heath, they examine the reasons that some ideas “stick” in our consciousness and others miss. The book itself is a can’t miss and outlines six steps to making an idea “sticky”:
None of the wines demonstrated a story that indicated anything approximating a “sticky idea.” And, irony of ironies: My takeaways from the tasting were about simple thoughts conveyed cleanly – “sticky” ideas: cereal palate training, MSG and wine and on and on.
The state of wine criticism, from all corners of seers and naysayers is in a state of disarray. With discernible quality hitting the $15 mark, imports bringing to bear economies that can’t be equaled from domestic wines and wine criticism coming from every corner, the story is all wineries have. Ultimately, the question of, “why should I care” isn’t a question about a rating or a score, but rather, about the hook that makes me interested – a story that builds on itself chapter by chapter.
April 4 2010
As my four nieces opened their Easter baskets (which include Hello Kitty Jelly Belly Jelly Beans), my thoughts turned to the launch of Hello Kitty wine this past week, an event that drew scrutiny from many people for its puzzling marketing applicability without a tableau to place it into context.
In fact, apropos to ponderous wonderment, Dr. Vino conducted a poll on his web site in which he asked for reader feedback about whether Hello Kitty wine was marketing to kids. 19% said “yes” they are marketing to kids and 18% of the vote said, “I have no flippin’ idea who they are targeting but I’m strangely confused and disturbed!”
Preschool backpacks and Easter jelly beans notwithstanding, Hello Kitty wine isn’t marketing to kids, at least not implicitly.
In fact, the source article on Hello Kitty wine from LA Weekly hints at the age-spanning phenomenon when it paraphrases Drew Hibbert from Innovations Spirits (the marketer for the Hello Kitty wine). Author of the LA Weekly article, Gendy Alimurung, notes, “They see the Hello Kitty brand identity as being somewhat mature at this stage and open to all kinds of product interpretations.”
It’s exactly that notion of, “open to all kinds of product interpretations” that makes Hello Kitty wine a more interesting wine marketing story than your usual wine-related cause célèbre, celebrity wine or fleeting story of questionable interest.
And, the answers about the elusive appeal of Hello Kitty aren’t too far away, either.
Coincidental to the launch of Hello Kitty wine, I’m in the middle of reading Buying In by Rob Walker. His 2008 book discusses the increasing meaning consumers are finding in brands as a proxy for symbolism that used to be filled by other things in our life.
Buying In references (in lengthy, early passages in the book) the interesting cultural phenomenon that is Hello Kitty.
The book notes, in reference to Hello Kitty creator Sanrio, a developer and distributor of character-branded products:
“Sanrio has been in the “character goods” business since the 1960s. By one count, its artists have dreamed up more than 450 cute little creatures. The word ‘character’ is a little misleading. The characters created by, for example, the Walt Disney Company or Marvel Entertainment first reach(es) the world through a comic book or a movie or television show. They have attributes, personalities and backstories. Sanrio’s characters (often animals) do not. They first reach the world by being emblazoned on products. Although they might be aesthetically charming, they are empty of specific meaning.”
A Sanrio designer, in 1974, created Hello Kitty (absent a mouth because she couldn’t design it in a ‘Cute Way’). The designer, Yuko Shimizu, later said, “I felt the power of Hello Kitty … and felt that it could be used as a tool for communication between people.”
According to Buying In’s secondary research, Hello Kitty is not:
“ …like Snoopy or Mickey Mouse, a character who has engaged in memorable adventures or has developed a personality of any kind. This is intentional. We work very hard to avoid things that would define the character … the simplicity is what made people understand Hello Kitty …”
Quoting a cultural scholar, Walker highlights that the most compelling factor of Hello Kitty success is, “projectability.”
The book goes on to quote both the cultural scholar and a Sanrio representative who say:
“Hello Kitty’s blank ‘cryptic’ simplicity … is among her greatest strengths; standing for nothing. She is waiting to be interpreted … without the mouth, it is easier for the person looking at Hello Kitty to project their feelings onto the character … the person can be happy or sad together with Hello Kitty …”
The analysis continues:
“Hello Kitty … is a mirror that reflects whatever image, desire, or fantasy an individual brings to it … what makes (Hello) Kitty so intriguing is that she projects entirely different meanings depending on the consumer … the cat is an icon that allows viewers to assign whatever meaning to her that they want …”
So, About that Hello Kitty Wine …
Hello Kitty wine, for me, is a very interesting case study-in-waiting. The wine business is excellent at developing a back-story as a part of a brand – think any one of thousands of wineries. Likewise, the business is also very good at manufacturing a brand that has arbitrary symbolism – think any one of hundreds of critter brands.
What the wine industry has no experience in whatsoever is a brand whose symbolism and meaning is based on “projectability” —the notion that users can use the wine as a prism to refract whatever they believe onto the wine drinking experience.
Wine is one of the most malleable of consumer products – it seemingly changes with every circumstance – light, mood, food, circumstance, etc. It seems only fitting that a brand play into that mercurial notion as well.
So, in sum, I hope your takeaway is not that Hello Kitty is or isn’t appealing to youth; I hope the takeaway is that Hello Kitty might be the very first wine brand in which the experience of the brand is defined not by the winery and their creation story, or a brand manager, but rather the user whose interaction with Hello Kitty is unique to them, and by virtue of that, it’s unique to the world of wine, as well.